Some Ukrainian refugees are still living with host families because there were “too many people and too few houses” to accommodate them, a review has found.

In the months after the Russian invasion of their country, the Scottish Government offered to sponsor Ukrainians to come to the UK as refugees, acting as a so-called “super sponsor”.

More than 21,000 visas were issued as part of the scheme before it was paused in 2022 amid soaring demand.

A review by Professor Linda Bauld praised the scheme, which she said met the objectives set when it was opened, but called for it to be formally closed.

However, the review also found that some people are still living with the host families they moved in with when they first came to Scotland or in homeless accommodation.

Linda Bauld
Professor Linda Bauld led the review (Andrew Milligan/PA)

The review said: “Finding sufficient and suitable housing for Ukrainian families was highly challenging and reflected national shortages across a wide range of housing types and local authorities.

“As one stakeholder summarised, the system faced ‘too many people and too few houses’.

“Many Ukrainians have now moved into settled accommodation, but some remain in homelessness pathways and others in longer-term hosting arrangements in private homes.”

The programme to resettle people from Ukraine was created in the years before Scotland declared a national housing emergency as a result of rising homelessness.

The review also found the lack of certainty for those coming to Scotland was “emotionally draining”.

The document said: “While they expressed gratitude for the safety and support while in this accommodation or hosting, they explained that prolonged uncertainty was emotionally draining.

“For families with children, repeated moves or the prospect of relocation created stress and a reluctance to disrupt schooling again.

“Ukrainians emphasised that stability, not simply shelter, defines meaningful resettlement.”

Prof Bauld’s review found that the programme had ultimately been “compassionate”.

“The findings demonstrate that Scotland’s response to the war in Ukraine was ambitious and unprecedented in scale, delivering a rapid and compassionate programme that provided safety to tens of thousands of displaced people,” the review said.

“The (super sponsor scheme) and the wider Warm Scottish Welcome programme enabled swift mobilisation across government, local authorities, the voluntary sector and communities, reflecting a strong collective commitment to humanitarian protection.

“At the same time, the review finds that the pace and scale of delivery exposed structural constraints — most notably in housing capacity, funding and data systems — that shaped both immediate delivery and longer-term outcomes.”

More than £450 million has been spent so far on Ukrainian resettlement by the Scottish Government, according to the review, with a further £16 million allocated for this year.

The review raised concerns about the cost if the scheme were to be started again, along with the impact on public services.

“Based on review findings, and evidence that not all the seven criteria have been met since the pause in 2022, the recommendation is that the super sponsor scheme should be formally closed to new applications,” the review found.

“This takes into account that Ukrainians still have a continuing route to sanctuary in the UK through the UK Government’s Homes for Ukraine scheme.”

The document made recommendations for future resettlement programmes, including a “place-based approach” to accommodating those coming to Scotland, given the pressures on the country’s housing system.

The partnership forged between Ukraine and Scotland during these difficult years is one that will forever remain a golden chapter in the history of relations between our nations

Andrii Madzianovskyi

In a foreword to the report, the Ukrainian consul in Edinburgh, Andrii Madzianovskyi, expressed his “deepest gratitude” to Scotland.

“Since the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine, Scotland has demonstrated extraordinary compassion and solidarity by welcoming more Ukrainians per head of population than any other UK nation,” he wrote.

“The rapid deployment of welcome hubs at Edinburgh and Glasgow airports, the innovative use of welcome accommodation including the passenger vessels, and the establishment of the Ukraine Longer Term Resettlement Fund are a testament to the agility and compassion of Scottish institutions.”

He added that the consulate “understands the rationale” for Scotland moving away from its initial emergency response as a result of pressures on public services.

He continued: “The partnership forged between Ukraine and Scotland during these difficult years is one that will forever remain a golden chapter in the history of relations between our nations.”

Scottish Government equalities minister Sumita Kumar said: “This review highlights much that we can be proud of.

“It shows that the Scottish Government, along with partners, moved quickly to help Ukrainian people fleeing Russia’s illegal war to come to Scotland and find refuge.

“I am deeply grateful to individuals, communities, organisations and public services that responded with such generosity, compassion and determination. The scale and speed of the response was extraordinary, and it reflected the very best of our country.”

Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton, who housed a refugee from Ukraine for nine months, said the Scottish Government should “not be patting themselves on the back”.

“There was a huge outpouring of goodwill towards Ukraine, with many families including my own offering somewhere to stay for those fleeing Putin’s war,” he said.

“However, we also saw hundreds reporting as homeless, slow progress in vetting hosts and a lack of support for local authorities to house and integrate our Ukrainian guests.

“It was another example of the Scottish Government wanting the good news photocall, before they had done the hard graft.”